Showing posts with label censorship. Show all posts
Showing posts with label censorship. Show all posts

02 October 2009

It's Got "a Lot of Bad, Bad Words in It": Whale Talk, by Chris Crutcher

Whale Talk by Chris Crutcher (2001)

Rumor has it that for most people, “high school” turned out to be little more than a variant spelling of “hell” – head cheerleaders and varsity quarterbacks excluded, I guess. I can’t speak from experience: my usually well-ordered memory seems to have misfiled most of what happened during my teens. I don’t know why, but the few lingering scraps seem to suggest that the rest is hidden out of willful self-defense. The renowned young-adult author Chris Crutcher, however, clearly does not suffer my peculiar memory malady: oh, no, Crutcher clearly remembers high school just fine, in all its excruciating, humiliating, embarrassing detail. He’s been making a living remembering those years for a couple of decades. Not only does he remember them, he shares them in all their glory – and Whale Talk is one of his best.

Somewhere in northeastern Washington, not far from Spokane, lies the town of Cutter. This bucolic little logging burg is, like many an American small town, proud of its high-school athletes; though Cutter might take things to extremes. As are most small western towns, Cutter is pretty homogeneous, which is just a fancy way of saying that almost everybody who lives there is White and Anglo-Saxon, and most are at least nominally Protestant. Cutter just happens to be where T. J. Jones lives with his adopted parents. The name on his birth certificate is “The Tao,” having been named after her favorite book by the birth mother with whom he spent his first two years. Considering that “Tao” is pronounced “dow,” it’s easy to see why The Tao Jones goes by a nickname (especially after the DJIA shed about a third of its value last year). T. J. also happens to be what lots of locals call a “mongrel” (a little further east in Idaho, he’d be called a “mud person”): his birth mother was Caucasian and his birth father (“the sperm donor”), Afro-Japanese. Sort of like Tiger Woods, T. J. Jones is a walking advertisement for what geneticists call “hybrid vigor,” ‘cause T. J. Jones has it all. A superb natural athlete, intelligent, and also darned good-looking; T. J. is everything one expects in a homecoming king – except perhaps he’s a little, errr, dusky. Oh, and he can have a wicked temper. Luckily, T. J. has a fantastic support system in his parents, his girlfriend Carly, and his therapist/friend, Georgia Brown (one of the other two people of color in Cutter) – otherwise he might have gone postal by his late teens.

Not all of T. J.’s classmates are so lucky. Like every school, every town – heck, every group of more than three people - there are students at Cutter High who are marginalized by their so-called peers for having the unmitigated gall to be “different.” Different can mean just about anything: developmentally disabled or super-intelligent, overweight, stick-like, painfully shy; anything that makes a kid stand out is grounds for exclusion… and worse. T. J. knows all about this exclusion stuff; having missed birthday parties and had dates broken because the parents of would-be friends don’t want “one of those people” in their homes. He’s getting through it, though, thanks to that support system.

When approached by his Senior English teacher to start a varsity swim team, T. J. is initially dubious. That’s for good reason: sure, he can swim; but not only does Cutter High not have a pool, there’s just one in the whole town (at the All Night Health Club), and it’s not exactly Olympic quality. And then T. J. has a brilliant idea… and soon Cutter High School has its first swim team ever. Only it’s a team composed entirely of the misfits, the marginalized, and the otherwise excluded – it’s a team with only one swimmer and no hope of ever winning a meet. Swim-team captain T. J. Jones has set his sights far higher than mere athletic accolades, however. He intends to give his six teammates something that the rest of their classmates have been trying to take away from them since first grade: their dignity. And so, the Cutter High swim team takes to the water: besides T. J., there’s a swimmer who weighs over three hundred pounds, one who’s the ultimate geek, one who’s a weight-lifting singer, one who’s so “average” that he just plain disappears in a crowd, one developmentally disabled, and one who has a weird limp and the baddest attitude ever – for darned good reason. Throw in a homeless man who sleeps in the health club at night as assistant coach, and you have all the ingredients of the most heartwarming sports story since Robert Redford blew out the stadium lights in “The Natural.”

If only it were that simple… but of course, it’s not.

Remember that T. J. is a “person of color”? Well, there are plenty of people in this corner of Washington who don’t much care for any color but lily-white – and chief among them is Rich Marshall, owner of the local lumber mill and the biggest cheese in Cutter’s alumni club. He spends more time roaming the halls of CHS with the football team than he does in his company office – and every time he sees T. J. Jones, something nasty just has to happen. See, Rich’s high school girlfriend Alicia left him and went away to college, then came back to Cutter with a mixed-race daughter. Rich married Alicia “anyway,” but little Heidi is collateral damage in a relationship that goes past dysfunctional to dangerous. When T. J. first meets Heidi, she’s attempting to scrub the “dirt” off of her arm – an arm almost exactly the same shade of brown as his.

T. J.’s senior year at Cutter High will be a delicate and sometimes dangerous balancing act for him and everyone around him: his swim teammates, his family, and little Heidi. It’s a year that will give him the strength he needs to be someone – perhaps someone great – and it’s a year that will take away one of the most precious things he has. To characterize Whale Talk as merely a “coming of age” tale is almost an insult to the growth T. J. Jones undergoes.

One pretty much knows what to expect when opening a young-adult novel written by Chris Crutcher: the protagonist will be an athletic high-school boy who doesn’t quite fit into the rigid caste system of his small high school. He could be a jock – the king of the jocks, probably – if he wants, but he finds the jocks small and shallow. He has great (a) great parent(s) and somehow makes a connection with that one teacher who puts him on the right path; meanwhile thumbing his nose at those adults who’ve never outgrown their high-school attitudes. He participates only in those interscholastic sports in which he competes against himself – track, swimming, cross-country – even though he could be an all-around athlete. He has a smart, slightly quirky girlfriend with whom he hasn’t had sex. And he knows in his heart of hearts that the people who run the cloistered little world of his high school are complete idiots. Chris Crutcher’s books are all that way; more like a prix fixe meal than a la carte…

That’s pretty much the outline of Whale Talk, like Running Loose and Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes before it (and, I’d wager, Chinese Finger Puzzle and Athletic Shorts, too). But even though the basic concept of his young-adult novels doesn’t stray far from the one central theme of “Be Your Own Person,” each novel also has its own flavor and its own set of issues. In the case of Whale Talk, the flavor is definitely chocolate – and the themes are much darker. Front and center is racism; the ugliest form of hatred – here directed not only at a strapping teenage boy but also at a little girl. Another theme is that of violence, violence for its own sake and violence born of ignorance – especially physical abuse of a wife or girlfriend… or a child. Crutcher does not pull any punches in Whale Talk – you are hereby warned not to come to this book looking for sanitized dialog or simple, happy-days solutions. The ending… is not as happy as it could be.

Whale Talk gets pretty rough. Crutcher has never been one to pull any punches when it comes to his plots or dialog. He’s softer on organized religion this time than he is in his other books I’ve read; though he still takes some shots at other favorite pastimes of the social conservatives. Such “problems” are never the reason that books like this are challenged – and Whale Talk has been challenged regularly ever since its publication in 2001. The reason that’s stated most often is “profanity”: I haven’t any idea what number he or she reached, but I can guarantee you that some stick-up-the-butt type somewhere has gone through the book counting and can tell you exactly how many “dirty” words are in the text. Then he went and screeched to a school board somewhere about how “we don’t let our children talk like that at school, so you shouldn’t make them read those words.”

The shame is, that while the dirty-word counters are making their little marks on a tally sheet somewhere and just about foaming at the mouth over the language, they aren't reading the rest of the words – and so they’re not getting the point. There are some sections of Whale Talk that are incredibly difficult to read, to be sure. The first scene between T. J. and little Heidi is a race between breaking your heart and turning your stomach – yet it is the utter realism of hideous words coming from the mouth of a child, the instant knowledge of what a little girl’s life must be like, that gives this scene power rarely seen in adult fiction – much less young adult writing. One courageous educator in Alabama said of complaints about the language in this book, “[the message of this book] is more important than the language used.” Cooler heads don’t always win, however: s/he was, of course, eventually overruled…

Whale Talk is a tough read, one that your teenager may well find disturbing. It isn’t disturbing because it uses “a lot of bad, bad words”; as a school board member in Decatur, Alabama, would have it. Whale Talk is disturbing because what’s in there is utterly, entirely possible.

21 September 2009

Running Loose: A Challenge to Bluenoses Everywhere

Running Loose by Chris Crutcher

I don't know about the rest of the guys out there, but if my senior year in high school had started out like Louie Banks', did, I'd have been one happy camper. Louie was a certified Big Man on Campus at THS – Trout (Idaho) High School – he had a starting slot on the football team, a better-'n-average GPA, and a cheerleader for a girlfriend. Maybe he was a big frog in a very small pond, but it sure seemed that Louie had it all. But that was before Coach Lednecky put a contract out on an opposing quarterback and called him some pretty unattractive names, starting with mild racial slurs and ending with the N-word. When Louie decided to stand on principle, Coach denied everything and almost the whole town turned against one confused seventeen-year-old.

Everybody, that is, except his best friend Carter, his parents Norm and Brenda, and Becky. Beautiful, smart, sexy Becky…

I don't know about the rest of the guys out there, but if my senior year in high school had turned out the way Louie's did, I might not have made it. It's a testament to a strong, levelheaded young man who'd been well prepared by loving parents that he made it through the trials and tribulations heaped on his head over those nine short months. It's even more astounding that he came through more grown up than he'd ever imagined. Dear Abby used to say, "If life gives you lemons, make lemonade." Louie Banks would definitely have had enough lemonade to keep Trout, Idaho, from getting thirsty for a long time. Here's to Louie, Running Loose on the back roads of western Idaho.

Like most Chris Crutcher books, Running Loose is written for adolescent males; guys who can identify with what Louie goes through every day at school (and what he does every night under the covers). It's a coming-of-age story in the sense that every seventeen-year-old has to come of age; but it's also a coming of age tale in the sense that Louie Banks does more growing up in that short year than a lot of "adults" have gotten around to doing by the time they're thirty.

Sure, the story is simplistic – it has to be, because people don't write another Ulysses for YA fiction. The idea is to entertain, to give the reader something he can identify with, and get across a hidden message or two. The twin messages in Running Loose are pretty powerful: a stand on principle is position of strength, and one must always roll with the punches. Louie Banks may shoot himself in the foot from time to time – he is, after all, only seventeen and therefore only about 10% as smart as he thinks he is – but when push comes to shove he makes some decisions that his parents can be proud of.

The odd thing about that last sentence is that there are parents out there who apparently would not be proud of their kids for acting like Louie Banks. Like many of Crutcher's books (Chinese Handcuffs, Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes, Athletic Shorts, and Ironman), Running Loose is a banned book. It's been challenged dozens of times over the years, not long ago (August, 2006) in Rochester, New York. According to the mother of a child given this book on a summer reading list, Running Loose is "soft-core pornography." She was described in a local newspaper as, "so upset by the book's use of racial terms and sexual references that she believed her son could gain little by reading the literature." Her husband said, "Some of the things in the book are unbelievable, and I was extremely surprised."

They must not have read the same book I did: here are just some of the lessons Louie Banks could teach the children of this couple:

1) Take a stand against intolerance and racism.
2) You do not need to have sex to prove you are in love.
3) Not every authority figure is a fit role model.

Soft-core pornography? Excuse me? The kid uses the words "hell" and "bastard" a couple of times. He does make not-infrequent references to, shall we say, the practice of self-gratification, but he gratifies himself, and his girlfriend's not involved.

Here is what is really wrong with the book, things that the couple from Rochester clearly want the libraries and schools to keep out of the sight and mind of their child: Louie calls his parents by their first names. He spends a (sexless) night with his girlfriend. Instead of the minister, the high school football coach, and the high school principal, some of the best advice Louie gets from adults comes from a bar owner and even the town drunk. And, worst of all, Louie blames an unfeeling God for some of the worst things that happen to him. Something tells me that those are the only passages that those Rochester parents ever read…


Find Running Loose at eBay

11 September 2009

Stand Up For Yourself!

Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes - Chris Crutcher


There are few things on the face of the earth that are crueler than a teenager confronted by someone who is even the slightest bit "different." Saddled with a genetic code that left him on the husky side - heck, all the way on the other side of husky at F-A-T - it was inevitable that Eric Calhoune's life in Junior High and High School would be an endless string of wedgies, swirlies, and general mayhem at the hands of the "normal" guys in his class. Since misery loves company, "united we stand," and all that; it's no wonder that Eric eventually joined forces with the other misfit in his class, Sarah Byrnes. Sarah Byrnes - never just "Sarah" - didn't have bad genes, though, she had the kind of family on whom dysfunctional families look down their noses. At the age of three, her face had been severely burned and her father had categorically refused to allow any attempt to reconstruct her horribly scarred visage. Sarah "Burns," indeed.

Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes - Chris Crutcher
All that was, however, before the high school swimming coach spotted Eric working out at the public pool. Long known as "Moby" (the great white whale) for both his size and his swimming ability, Eric reluctantly accepted her invitation to try out for the team. The daily three-hour workouts began to melt off excess poundage, and Eric found himself gorging like a bulimic prom queen in hopes of Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes. And when Sarah Byrnes found out what he was doing and why, she just whacked him upside the head and told him to cut it out and slim down. That's what friends do... That's also why after Sarah Byrnes stopped talking and got moved to the funny farm, Eric was the only kid from school to visit.

But Eric has plenty of other things on his plate besides visiting Sarah Byrnes: the swim team's prepping for state meets, the erstwhile fatty may actually finally have a girlfriend, and the fur is about to start flying at debates in his very special "Contemporary American Thought" class. This young man is in for a wild ride over the next few days; a wild ride that has "Chris Crutcher" written all over it.

Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes follows a pattern similar to that of other Crutcher books, books such as Running Loose. A teenaged boy finds his life changed by his interaction with a classic role model - an athletic coach - who also helps teach him some of life's most valuable lessons, even while a cadre of lemon-pussed adults tries to keep the young man "in his place." Crutcher's adolescent males seem to inhabit a world in which athletics and hard work are the crucibles in which "real men" are formed; a world in which there are two kinds of adults and the two camps seem to be pretty uneasy around each other.

From a literary standpoint, Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes isn't quite as well-written as Running Loose or Crutcher's autobiography, King of the Mild Frontier. The characters are just as rich and the lessons just as profound, but it just seems sometimes as if Crutcher is trying too hard to thumb his nose at his detractors. Unlike other Crutcher books I've read, this one seems just a little contrived - of course, he sets a pretty darned high bar. But his writing isn't why a certain group of people foam at the mouth whenever his name's mentioned...

What can one say about Chris Crutcher? As one of the most frequently-challenged authors of the past two decades, Crutcher continually stays centered on the radar screens of the bluenose set for his ever-frank approach to the lifestyle of teenaged males. He's not one to tiptoe around the subject of self-gratification (so near at hand... errr... dear to the heart of teenaged males); not one to soft-pedal the cloud of hormones that follows every teenaged boy like the cloud of dirt around Pigpen in "Charlie Brown." Worse, Crutcher is never shy about portraying a subset of adults as undeserving of the respect of youngsters - and worst of all, these inglorious adults seem to often occupy positions such as preacher, teacher, and principal. Small wonder that many would-be censors aren't too fond of him.

The distaste of challengers for Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes seems at times odd, since - just as Louie Banks in Running Loose - Eric Calhoune, hero of Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes, leads a pretty tame life. He doesn't have sex (at least not with anyone else). He doesn't drink, smoke, swear (much) or do drugs. Instead, he's a quiet, well-mannered young man who's hard-working, a good friend to Sarah Byrnes and Ellerby, and a loving son. What's not to like?

Be that as it may, in truth Crutcher does at times seem to delight in poking the hornet's nest of censorship. In Staying Fat..., he touches on a broad array of topics from which some people would much rather shield their kids. The "Contemporary American Thought" class discussion of abortion is a case in point; but Crutcher's plot also brims with topics such as child abuse, suicide, hypocrisy, the existence of a God, and even adult sexuality. While on the surface the book is about self-realization - the dedication is to "All those who finally stand up for themselves" - Crutcher clearly intends to remind his audience that not every Evangelical Christian is a saint (Falwell, Hagedorn, Bakker...) and not every teacher has the best interests of his students in mind.

So why is Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes so often challenged? Darned if I can tell... OK, in truth it's pretty obvious: my guess (since I have a blood relative who is the kind of person who'd lobby to have this book banned) is that their objections include:

• a classroom dialogue on the topic of abortion - and not just a one-sided presentation, a dialogue
• an evangelical Christian who is a pure-D hypocrite
• a "mainstream" Christian minister who takes no guff from his evangelical brethren
• evil parents; parents who abandon children and/or physically and emotionally abuse them
• the occasional appearance of mild profanity
• a scattering of offhand (groan) references to masturbation
• an attempted suicide
• an adult who uses children as pawns
• a divorced mother who has boyfriends who... gasp! stay over!

In short, like my narrow-minded relative, the idea is to make certain that children are not exposed to other belief systems and other lifestyles. For that, bluenoses, I give you a big, fat raspberry: ppppppbbbbbbbbbbbttttttttttttt!
copyright © 2009-2017 scmrak

06 September 2009

Finding God in Your Own Way: Bless Me Ultima

Bless Me, Ultima - Rudolfo Anaya


In the summer before he turned seven, there came many changes in the life of Antonio Márez; changes such as the first day of school, where he began to unlock the magic of letters and learn his first English. There was the return of his three older brothers, unharmed, from the war in Europe and Asia. But the greatest change of all was his parents' decision to welcome into their home the aging healer la Grande, or Ultima. This great curandera, midwife, and philosopher was famous both on the wilds of the eastern New Mexico llano, where Tony's father's people herded sheep and cattle, and in the rich bottomlands along the Pecos River where his mother's family tilled their fields and tended orchards. From the moment he first saw Ultima, Antonio realized that the two shared some special bond; that their fates were linked in a manner he could not describe.

For the Márez family, life was simple and yet complex: like some New World Romeo and Juliet, the marriage of Tony's parents joined rancher to farmer, with old enmity between the families still lying just beneath the surface. Forced by marriage to give up an almost nomadic existence on the llano, yet too proud to be a farmer, Tony's father instead worked for the state and drank to calm his genetic wanderlust. Meanwhile, his mother pined quietly for the rich soil of her family's valley and dreamed that her youngest son would someday be called to the priesthood. Still, theirs managed to be a happy family, and the next few years were happy days for Tony.

One day, Tony's uncle came to ask a favor of la Grande: another of Tony's uncles lay on his deathbed; the doctor could not help and the priest was of no help, either. Could the great curandera heal him; could she reverse the spell cast on him by an evil village woman? This was how Tony learned of Ultima's full power. There was another power in the young boy's life: the church of his mother, a devout Catholic. As First Communion approached and he completed his Catechism classes, Tony thought he could feel the majesty and glory of the Church - at clear odds with his friends from town, who teased Tony unmercifully about his faith, with that special cruelty of which only young children seem capable.

A child is a sort of psychic compass, pointing toward the greatest power in his vicinity, and Tony was no exception. He seemed to have no difficulty concocting a philosophy that integrated his mother's Catholicism, Ultima's shamanist spirituality, and even pantheic influences from his friend Cico with the tale of a godlike golden carp. Tony's faith in all three influences, however, would be tested early - and often - in his young life. Which of the three would provide the protection he most desired, protection against evil? Which, indeed...

Renowned Chicano author Rudolfo Anaya allows that his classic novel Bless Me, Ultima (also published in Spanish as Bendíceme, Ultima) is partially autobiographical in that it records parts of his childhood in the Santa Rosa area of eastern New Mexico. He's also been known to state that - although curanderas (traditional healers and herbalists) still plied their trade in his childhood, and in fact do so to this day - none like Ultima was part of his youth: instead, Ultima came to him in a dream as he began writing. If you ask me, that was one heckuva dream...

The life of a little boy in wartime New Mexico was wildly different from today: no internet or television, not even a radio; no soccer or Little League, no Cub Scouts or 4-H. Instead, Tony's days were filled by his chores around the house and his games with the boys from school. Anaya recounts that play as rough-and-tumble, filled to the brim by boasting and fighting, with curses hurled at one's playmates at the drop of a hat. Antonio's gang were all quite different from their younger friend, however, lacking both his faith and his desire to learn. They were more the type who would end up with DA haircuts and hot rods in high school, where Tony was obviously destined to become a man of learning - after all, Ultima said he would. Those of us who are interested in learning other languages (particularly the naughty words) will be pleased with Anaya's tale, which is chucky-jam full of both English and New Mexican Spanish maledictions (most of which I'd already learned from John Nichols in The Milagro Beanfield War).

The novel faithfully records a critical period in young Tony's life. It's a life filled by a loving family, friends of many stripes, and a strong vein of religion. Most of all, however, it's also a life guided by the mysterious Ultima, who many think a bruja or witch. As L. Frank Baum pointed out before Rudolfo Anaya was even born, however, there are not just wicked witches in this world: there are good witches as well.

Bless Me, Ultima is usually called a "coming-of-age" tale. In certain aspects, Tony's story is a typical coming-of-age tale; recording as it does the formative years of a young boy when he first leaves his mother's side for that great collection of stimuli called "school." Yet I personally consider "coming of age" a misnomer: instead, Anaya's novel is a coming-of-faith novel. In its three short years, little Tony weathered many crises of faith; witnessing death up close and personal, and observing the evils of the Church's deadliest sins, particularly wrath. At each of these critical moments, even as he took his First Communion, he felt a sort of emptiness in the religion that Europeans had forced upon his Native ancestors. Guided by Ultima's power, by her quiet competence and ancient calm, Tony was eventually able to reconcile his questioning with a different sort of spirituality, a spirituality that finds harmony with creation instead of attempts to control it.

An interesting and thought-provoking memoir, not to mention a novel that was crucial in helping elevate Latino literature in the eyes of the literary community.

Almost since the day it first hit store shelves in 1972, Anaya's novel has been challenged and banned in schools and communities nationwide. On the opposite end of the spectrum, it's also been chosen as a "community reads" book on several occasions (usually by liberal bastions such as Boulder, Colorado). Challenges generally cite the language (both English and Spanish) used by characters in the book, the presence of a brothel in Tony's little town (frequented by his brother Andrew), and the "glorification of witchcraft" - even before Harry Potter! It's a poorly-kept secret, though, that the main objection of most protestors to Bless Me, Ultima is that when Tony decides on a religious path top follow, Christianity loses out to a form of Native American animism - the detested "Earth Worship" they call "paganism" (see Gaia). Most practitioners of the type of Christianity that feels threatened by a spirituality embracing all of Earth as a blessed gift seem ignorant of the manner in which their own religion has appropriated pagan and animist symbology and celebrations into its theism, which is probably just as well: you wouldn't want their heads to explode (it would be messy).

Though a novel whose main character is a pre-teen boy, Bless Me, Ultima is far too mature for children of Tony's age. Even if you don't object to the frequent bilingual maledictions (one wonders if challengers are bamboozled by the lack of a glossary to define words like cabrón or jodido), the themes are clearly beyond the ken of preteens; even most early teens. I see no reason why a mature high-schooler (sadly, a vanishing breed) should not gain from the reading, however. If you're the type of person who believes that your child deserves a chance to think for him- or her-self, slip a copy into their stocking come Christmas - or Winter Solstice, if you prefer...

04 September 2009

Death is a Three-Letter Word: N-A-M

Fallen Angels - Walter Dean Myers

For many men of my generation, the Baby Boomers, death might best be personified by three simple letters: N-A-M. Fought in a far-off land for reasons that were often unclear even to the combatants, the war in Vietnam still looms both as one of this country’s most humbling and its most divisive experiences. It seems capable of galvanizing the country’s most easily polarized even today, more than thirty-five years after the last jarhead scrambled into the last helicopter to lift from the grounds of the U. S. Embassy in Saigon. The war and the men and women who directed it, fought in it, and died in it have been memorialized in scores of motion pictures and thousands (if not tens of thousands) of books. One such volume, directed toward a young adult audience, is Walter Dean Myers’ Fallen Angels. Myers’ book has garnered its share of awards: it’s received a Coretta Scott King Award; and was cited in the American Library Association’s (ALA) Margaret A. Edwards Award presented to Myers for his lifetime contribution to young adult literature. It’s also generated its share of controversy: Fallen Angels stands at number twenty-four on the ALA list of 100 most frequently challenged and banned books (1990-2000) and number six in the ALA’s list of most frequently challenged books of the twenty-first century. But why? To understand, perhaps you must understand the story…

Fallen Angels is not a deep philosophical discussion of the war in Vietnam; it’s a single soldier’s diary of his one and only tour of duty in-country. As seen through the eyes of seventeen-year-old Richie Perry, Vietnam is an alien land; dark and steamy and full of danger the youngster from Harlem has never sensed before. He misses his mother, his brother, shooting hoops with his friends. The other “men” – men by virtue of being a soldier in the midst of a war zone, not for their age – of Charlie Company become more than bunkmates: white, brown, or black they become brothers for having shared hell on earth. Though out in “The World” back in 1967 racial tension is shaking the cities; in Chu Lai and Tam Ky, everyone bleeds the same bright red blood no matter what the color of his skin. It’s a lesson Richie has learned quickly…

Through vivid descriptions of the few months of his tour, Richie Perry bears witness to the insanity inherent in war; to the moral ambiguity that so characterizes the war in Vietnam even to this day. His descriptions of battle action are raw; his record of a boy-soldier’s emotions powerful and lucid. It’s an account that is almost hackneyed for the appearance of all the standard highlights of a war narrative: the sudden death of the guy standing next to you; the slow and agonizing death of a man-child; the battle-hardened veteran NCO dismissive of his charges; the officer exposing troops to additional danger as he’s bucking for a promotion. Since the war is Vietnam, we know to expect racial hatred of anyone small and Asian; watch for the round-eyes’ frustration at their inability to distinguish between friend and foe; await the overreaction of the American soldiers to one too many deaths.

In the crucible of war, Richie Perry becomes something more than he was when he arrived. And yet he returns to his home diminished…

Walter Dean Myers penned Fallen Angels in 1988, fifteen years after the fall of Saigon and twenty years after the events chronicled in his book. He takes his title from the prayer uttered by a young lieutenant upon the death of a soldier under his command:

“Lord, let us feel pity for Private Jenkins, and sorrow for ourselves, and all the angel warriors that fall. Let us fear death, but let it not live within us. Protect us, O Lord, and be merciful unto us. Amen.”
Based in part on his own experiences as a soldier in the early 1960s, Myers’ depiction of life on the battlefields of Vietnam had little different to say when it was published in 1988; long after movies like “Coming Home” and “Apocalypse Now” had inserted catchphrases like “Charlie don’t surf” or “I love the smell of napalm in the morning” into the American consciousness. Richie Perry’s story is, however, even more powerful because he becomes everyman by simply surviving from day to day. His is a story told in a stark, linear narrative; unvarnished by flowery language and maudlin sentiments – the words of a simple young man who has to conserve all his strength for the business of surviving. It is this straightforward simplicity that imbues Fallen Angels with such power – and has made it a classic in the genre of soldier’s diaries, just as “Vietnam” made death a three-letter word.

When people challenge books in schools and libraries, they are usually required to state the rationale for their objection. Fallen Angels has been challenged often in the past twenty years, ostensibly on the basis of raw language and – oddly enough, for a book written by a Black man about a Black soldier – for racism. Indeed, words beginning with S, H, D, and F do occur in its pages, albeit somewhat less often than one might expect of a war story. The so-called N word also makes an appearance or two, much in the same context as in gangsta rap (which, frankly, doesn’t say much in its favor).

Fallen Angels has also been challenged for “promoting homosexuality”: one character might be homosexual, while another says he doesn’t much care as long as the guy can fight. Yup, that’s “promotion” all right… It’s likewise been challenged in some venues as “pornographic” (I kid you not) and a “sex manual” (an odd description, given that the protagonist is still a virgin at the end of the book). Perhaps the only true grounds for objection might be for its violent nature; but if war isn’t violent, then what is? Besides, few challengers (if any) complain of the book's violence.

It’s curious that protests against Fallen Angels increased in the first few years of the twenty-first century, at precisely the same time that the country ramped up for, entered, and prosecuted a “good” war in the Middle East; one more “recovery” from the bad taste the war in Vietnam a generation ago left in the nation’s collective mouth. Perhaps the book’s open discussion of atrocities committed during that earlier war threatened some of the more PATRIOTic Americans, who felt that leaving it on library shelves might give young men and women pause when considering entering the armed forces. Indeed, Myers candidly discusses mutiny, “fragging” a superior officer, mutilation of corpses, a friendly fire incident, “collateral damage” involving the population of an entire village, bogus body counts, and a host of other shameful acts exposed by the memoirs of Vietnam veterans (although nothing about the humiliation and torture of prisoners of war). One can only hope that the forces of “right” are not so cynical as to attempt to put a positive spin on the Vietnam era by silencing critical viewpoints. One can only hope…


31 August 2009

What do you call a guy with no arms, no legs, no ears...

Johnny Got His Gun - Dalton Trumbo


He was just your ordinary joe: nineteen, maybe twenty years old. Somebody's son. Somebody's brother. Somebody's friend. Somebody's co-worker. Somebody's lover. And then one spring day he stepped aboard a troop train in Los Angeles, bound for the trenches of the war that the politicians said would make the world safe for democracy; the first step of a journey that would never end. His name was Joe Bonham, and he took up arms to answer a call he didn't even understand. What happened to Joe after that should never happen to any living creature.

Johnny Got His Gun - Dalton Trumbo
A couple of decades ago a spate of tasteless little jokes made all the rounds; each followed a simple pattern: "What do you call a guy with no arms and no legs sitting on your front porch?"* Oh, there were dozens of 'em, all answered with a name or nickname; none of them really all that witty -- just sort of the elephant jokes of the eighties. They do, however, bring us to the question in the title:

What do you call a guy with no arms, no legs, no ears, no face, no eyes, no mouth, no nose... Dalton Trumbo called him Joe Bonham, and made his GI Joe the subject of the twentieth century's most renowned antiwar novel, Johnny Got His Gun. Trumbo's novel was written about the First World War and published at the dawn of World War II. The book's been reprinted more than forty times; it was made into a movie at the height of the Vietnam war. Today, more than sixty years after first publication, Trumbo's narrative remains ageless, relying on a simple message spoken in the voice of a frightened young man.
You can always hear the people who are willing to sacrifice somebody else's life. They're pretty loud and they talk all the time. You can find them in the churches and schools and newspapers and legislatures and congress. That's their business. They sound wonderful. Death before dishonor. This ground sanctified by blood. These men who died so gloriously. They shall not have died in vain. Our noble dead.

Hmmmm...

But what do the dead say?
This is a text that is as distant from Stephen Coonts and Dale Brown as one could possibly get. There is no glorious battle action, no fall-on-the-grenade heroism, no gritty cigarette-behind-the ear dialogue, no bombs bursting in air, no crisp pennants flapping in the breeze. No war. Everything that occurs in Johnny Got His Gun happens inside Joe's head, for -- as we learn right along with our narrator -- his brain is the only thing left that works.

Joe imagines a telephone ringing, ringing, ringing in the distance -- and he dreams that his mother is calling the bakery where he worked to tell him his father just died. When he realizes that the only sounds he hears are inside his skull, he knows he's deaf. But that's OK, a deaf man can get by if he works at it. Chapter by chapter, we see Joe as a boy, a young man -- we see the funny tales of his co-workers at the bakery. We go fishing with him and his dad in the Rockies. We share his last night with Kareen, the young woman whose ring he wears. But the hand that wore the ring is gone, and so is the other. Chapter by chapter, we are led through an horrific inventory of a battered body. No legs. No arms. His entire face wiped out by an exploding artillery shell -- deaf, blind, dumb, no lips, no tongue, no nose, no eyes. How can he not go mad?
I can't. I can't stand it. Scream. Move. Shake something. Make a noise any noise. I can't stand it. Oh no no no.

Please I can't. Please no. Somebody come. Help me. I can't lie here forever like this until maybe years from now I die. I can't. Nobody can. It isn't possible.

I can't breathe but I'm breathing. I'm so scared I can't think but I'm thinking. Oh please please no. No no. It isn't me. Help me. It can't be me. Not me. No no no.

Oh please oh oh please. No no no please no. Please.

Not me.
Years before Dr. Elizabeth Kubler-Ross tallied the stages of dying, Trumbo wrote all about the pleading.

And then Trumbo wrote about the acceptance. Here lies a man who, by any reckoning including his own, would certainly be better off dead. He's imprisoned inside a body that retains only one sense; touch; but lacks fingertips with which to feel. Yet he uses what little remains to try to master his environment: first, he tackles the passage of time. How do you know how long a day is when you cannot see the sunrise, or hear a clock? Joe masters time with logic and persistence. Having beaten the clock in his own way, he attempts to communicate; and the idea that he wants to communicate is that his mutilated body should be the ultimate example for peace. But it is not to be.

The language of Johnny Got His Gun is the language of a young man, literate but not well educated. He makes no impassioned polysyllabic pleas for peace, he speaks only in the plain language of working-class folk. The sentences are short, the sentences are simple; flowing in a stream from Joe's consciousness. The thoughts are simple and sincere, expressed in self-talk; for there is no other way for Joe to express himself. Trumbo's choice of language is much of the reason why this work has lasted, because it is couched in terms that almost anyone can understand.

The life Joe relives and retells is one that each of us can relate to: he remembers teenage angst, first love, a boy's coming of age, a child's loss of his father. Each time he realizes yet another part of his body is gone, he slips into memory of the sensations he can never have again. The sound of his mother reading "'Twas the Night Before Christmas"; the sound of artillery shells whistling to earth. The scent of the pines high in the Colorado Rockies; the odor of a dead body in no-mans-land. The glorious colors of a desert sky at sunset; the sight of rats feasting on a dead body in the trenches. The touch of his lover's hand; the cold muck in a foxhole. All gone; the good and the bad.

A poster child for peace indeed.

On censorship and Book Banning:

In the first (1959) of his two introductions to Johnny Got His Gun, Dalton Trumbo wrote that the timing of the book's first publication was unfortunate. Few but the most radical would disagree with the oft-repeated sentiment that, if any war was ever necessary, it was World War II. Although a dedicated pacifist, Trumbo allowed the book to go out of print for the duration of the war once the US had entered in 1941:
After Pearl Harbor its subject matter seemed as inappropriate to the times as the shriek of bagpipes... My correspondents, a number of whom used elegant stationery and sported tidewater addresses... proposed a national rally for peace-now, with me as cheer leader; they promised (and delivered) a letter campaign to pressure the editor for a fresh edition.

Nothing could have convinced me so quickly that Johnny was exactly the sort of book that shouldn't be reprinted until the war's end. The publishers agreed.
Long a dedicated leftist, Trumbo chose this self-censorship when he found his work becoming a vehicle for right-wing opposition to America's entrance into World War II. He was, however, more than happy to find its resurgence as a rallying point for a new generation of antiwar activists during the Vietnam era, as evidenced by these words in his second foreword to the book, circa 1971:

Numbers have dehumanized us. Over breakfast coffee we read of 40,000 Americans dead in Vietnam. Instead of vomiting, we reach for the toast. Our morning rush through crowded streets is not to cry murder but to hit that trough before somebody else gobbles our share.

An equation: 40,000 dead young men = 3,000 tons of bone and flesh, 124,000 pounds of brain matter, 50,000 gallons of blood, 1,840,000 years of life that will never be lived, 100,000 children who will never be born. (The last we can afford: there are too many starving children in the world already.)
Trumbo was himself the victim of perhaps the one of the most heinous act of censorship in American history. When the longtime Communist was called to testify before Joseph McCarthy's House Unamerican Activities Committee in 1947, he refused to speak. For this "contempt," he was jailed briefly, and blacklisted. The blacklist period lasted from 1947 until 1960, when director Otto Preminger announced that he would hire Trumbo as screenwriter for "Exodus." Trumbo was not by any means inactive during his blacklist period. The prolific writer worked under several different pseudonyms (including James Bonham). His work during and after the blacklist period includes the screenplays for "Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo," "Papillon," and "Exodus," among others.

In what may well be the ultimate triumph of an artist over censorship, in 1956 the Blacklisted Trumbo won a screenwriting Academy Award for "The Brave Ones," written under the assumed name Robert Rich.

* you call him Matt.
copyright © 2009-2017 scmrak